Agenda: Class 4
ET 690 Educational Technology Seminar
- All technological change is a Faustian bargain. For every
advantage a new technology offers, there is always a corresponding
- The advantages and disadvantages of new technologies are
never distributed evenly among the population. This means that
every new technology benefits some and harms others.
- Embedded in every technology there is a powerful idea, sometimes
two or three powerful ideas. Like language itself, a technology
predisposes us to favor and value certain perspectives and accomplishments
and to subordinate others. Every technology has a philosophy,
which is given expression in how the technology makes people
use their minds, in what it makes us do with our bodies, in how
it codifies the world, in which of our senses it amplifies, in
which of our emotional and intellectual tendencies it disregards.
- A new technology usually makes war against an old technology. It competes with it for time, attention, money, prestige, and
- Technological change is not additive; it is ecological. A
new technology does not merely add something; it changes everything.
- Because of the symbolic forms in which information is encoded,
different technologies have different intellectual and
- Because of the accessibility and speed of their information,
different technologies have different political biases.
- Because of their physical form, different technologies have
different sensory biases.
- Because of the conditions in which we attend to them, different
technologies have different social biases.
- Because of their technical and economic structure, different
technologies have different content biases.
--Postman, pp. 192-193
"We need to ask what characteristics of the technology
interact with the social context of its use to benefit some people
at the expense of others and to reinforce existing power relations;
and what possibilities exist for constructing alternative contexts
of use favoring more progressive outcomes, for breaking down existing
power relations. The relevant issues are demonstrably not technical
ones; this is what I mean in advocating the view that technology
is a social practice." --Bromley (in Bromley and Apple, p.
"Are these the values we want influencing our children."
--Healy, p. 34
"The most interactive experience you ever had with your
computer is less interactive than the most meaningless experience
you ever had with your cat!" --Tom Snyder (as cited in Healy,
"If anything, these distractions have begun to serve an
almost accidental function: They give people a false sense of
shrewdness. Once anyone penetrates the Net's first few layers
of junk, it's easy to think that the hard work has been done and
that whatever information remains should be relatively solid.
When it comes to learning the principles of academic research,
nothing could be further from the truth." --Oppenheimer,
"The intellectual ethic of a technology is rarely recognized by its
inventors. They are usually so intent on solving a particular problem
or untangling some thorny scientific or engineering dilemma that they
don't see the broader implications of their work. The users of the
technology are also usually oblivious to its ethic...Ultimately, it's an invention's intellectual ethic that has the most
profound effect on us. The intellectual ethic is the message that a
medium or other tool transmits in the minds and culture of its users." Carr, pp. 45-46
"Because language is, for human beings, the primary vessel of conscious
thought, particularly higher forms of thought, the technologies that
restructure language tend to exert the strongest influence over our
intellectual lives." pp. 50-51
- Questions and Announcements
- Thanks to Kristen for Bringing the Snacks
- Class Participation
- I sent emails earlier this week to two groups of people - NO EMAILS THIS WEEK
- Those whose in-class participation was too low in quantity or late
- Those whose in-class participation was noted for high quality
- Those who weren't noted should not worry as the participation
overall was very good
- Discussion: Carr, Prologue - Chapter 3, Let by Kristen and Katie
- Postman Paper due next class
- Read, Carr, Chapters 4-6
- Snacks Next Time: Katie
Return to ET690 Home Page.
This page was prepared by Dr.
David M. Marcovitz.
Last Updated: September 28, 2011