| 1. | St. Peter's | 3:11.65 | 32 |
| Kelly, Robert - SO | McGrath, Joe - SR | ||
| Santiago, Joe - JR | Rose, Karl - SO |
| 2. | Niagara | 3:13.32 | 26 |
| O'Connell, Dan - FR | Newell, Chris - JR | ||
| Gabriel, Trevor - JR | Rinkus, Duane - FR |
| 3. | Loyola | 3:17.67 | 24 |
| Brandt, Casey - SR | Kelly, Tim - FR | ||
| Loper, Ashley - FR | Holloway, Chris - SO |
| 4. | Iona | 3:22.65 | 22 |
| Schneider, Chad - SR | Judge, Kevin - SR | ||
| Henning, Jim - SO | Flynn, Brian - SO |
| 5. | Canisius | 3:23.10 | 20 |
| Sullivan, Brian - FR | Backsten, Mike - FR | ||
| Callahan, Mike - SR | Stefankiewicz, Steve - JR |
| 6. | Fairfield | 3:24.33 | 18 |
| Burns, Jason - SR | O'Keefe, Kevin - FR | ||
| Reddy, Jon - JR | Digiacomo, Brian - SO |
| 1. | Niagara | 3:24.24 |
| O'Connell, Dan - FR | Doberman, John - SR | ||
| Gabriel, Trevor - JR | Rinkus, Duane - FR |
| 2. | Loyola | 3:26.13 |
| Baxendale, Jon - SR | Abrams, Chris - FR | ||
| Mercer, John - SR | Evans, Chris - JR |
| 3. | Canisius | 3:26.82 |
| Stefankiewicz, Steve - JR | Callahan, Mike - SR | ||
| Backsten, Mike - FR | Sullivan, Brian - FR |
| 4. | Fairfield | 3:29.78 |
| O'Keefe, Kevin - FR | Digiacomo, Brian - SO | ||
| Griek, Mike - SO | Reddy, Jon - JR |
| 5. | St. Peter's | 3:34.85 |
| McGrath, James - SO | McGrath, Joe - SR | ||
| Thompson, Jonathon - SO | Umana, Marty - SR |
| 6. | Iona | 3:37.35 |
| Judge, Kevin - SR | Lynch, Gerard - SO | ||
| Scott, Kevin - FR | Henning, Jim - SO |